Question 1 · Hard
A 58-year-old man has had right lower lobe pneumonia for 6 days, with fever persisting despite antibiotics. A right pleural effusion is tapped; the fluid is cloudy but not frank pus. Pleural fluid: protein 42 g/L, LD 1,350 U/L, glucose 1.9 mmol/L (34 mg/dL), pH 7.08 measured at once on a blood gas analyzer from a heparinized syringe with no air or local anesthetic; Gram stain negative. Serum: protein 70 g/L, LD 260 U/L (upper reference limit 250 U/L), glucose 6.4 mmol/L (115 mg/dL). The chest team drains parapneumonic effusions with a pH below 7.20. The best interpretation is:
- AExudate; pH unreliable, repeat the tap
- BExudate; complicated effusion needing drainage
- CTransudate; no further fluid tests needed
- DExudate; uncomplicated, antibiotics alone
Show answerHide answer
Answer: B · Exudate; complicated effusion needing drainage
By Light's criteria the fluid is an exudate on all three counts: the protein ratio is 42/70 = 0.60 (above 0.5), the LD ratio is 1,350/260 = 5.2 (above 0.6), and the fluid LD is far above two-thirds of the serum upper limit (167 U/L). In a parapneumonic exudate, a pH below 7.20, a low glucose and a very high LD show that bacteria and neutrophils in the pleural space are making acid and using glucose. This is a complicated parapneumonic effusion, which needs chest tube drainage even though the fluid is not yet frank pus (empyema) and the Gram stain is negative. The pH is reliable because the fluid was collected without air or lidocaine and measured at once: air falsely raises the pH and lidocaine lowers it.
- A: The sample was anaerobic, without lidocaine and measured at once, so the pH is reliable.
- C: All three of Light's criteria are met, so the fluid is an exudate.
- D: A pH below 7.20 and a low glucose mark an effusion that antibiotics alone will not clear.