Question 1 · Easy
In the clinic, a man calmly says he plans to stab his neighbour tonight and asks the nurse to keep this secret. What should she do?
- ARaise it at next week's team meeting
- BWrite it in the notes and act only if he says it again
- CKeep it secret, as everything a patient says is confidential
- DSay she cannot keep it secret and report it at once so the neighbour is protected
Show answerHide answer
Answer: D · Say she cannot keep it secret and report it at once so the neighbour is protected
Confidentiality is a strong duty but not an absolute one. When a patient makes a serious, specific threat against an identifiable person, the duty to protect that person outweighs it. The nurse tells the patient honestly that she cannot keep this promise, reports at once to the doctor and her manager, and follows hospital policy so the police or the person at risk can be warned. Only the information needed to prevent harm is shared, and the disclosure is documented.
- A: A threat for tonight cannot wait for a routine meeting.
- B: Waiting for a repeat threat leaves the neighbour exposed to harm tonight.
- C: A serious threat to a named person is a recognised exception to confidentiality.