Question 1 · Hard
A manual anti-HCV ELISA is run on pre-employment samples. The kit insert states: the run is valid if every negative control (NC) OD is below 0.150 and the mean positive control OD is at least 0.800; the cut-off is the mean NC OD plus 0.250; samples with an OD at or above the cut-off are reactive; samples from 10% below the cut-off up to the cut-off are in the gray zone and must be retested in duplicate. Results: NC 0.058, 0.064 and 0.061; positive controls 1.420 and 1.510; sample 17 OD 0.292. How should sample 17 be handled?
- ANonreactive: its OD is below the cut-off
- BInvalid run: repeat the whole plate
- CReactive: its OD is above 0.250
- DGrey zone: retest it in duplicate
Show answerHide answer
Answer: D · Grey zone: retest it in duplicate
First check validity: every NC is below 0.150 and the mean positive control is 1.465, so the run is valid. The mean NC is (0.058 + 0.064 + 0.061) ÷ 3 = 0.061, giving a cut-off of 0.061 + 0.250 = 0.311 and a gray-zone lower limit of 0.9 × 0.311 = 0.280. Sample 17, at 0.292 (S/CO 0.94), falls in the gray zone, so it is retested in duplicate before any result is reported. Calling it nonreactive ignores the gray zone, and calling it reactive uses 0.250 as the cut-off without adding the NC mean. The gray zone exists because results just below the cut-off include some early or weak true positives.
- A: It is below the cut-off but inside the gray zone, which needs a duplicate retest.
- B: Every NC is below 0.150 and the positive mean is 1.465, so the run is valid.
- C: 0.250 is the constant added to the NC mean, not the cut-off itself.