Question 1 · Hard
A healthy 24-year-old woman from Assam has antenatal screening: Hb 11.8 g/dL, MCV 71 fL, MCH 23 pg, RBC 5.2 million/µL, serum ferritin normal. Cation-exchange HPLC: HbA 69%, HbF 0.6%, and 28% in the HbA2 window (HbA2 in beta-thalassaemia trait is usually 3.5-7%). The most likely interpretation is:
- ASickle cell trait
- BHaemoglobin E trait
- CHaemoglobin D Punjab trait
- DBeta-thalassaemia trait
Show answerHide answer
Answer: B · Haemoglobin E trait
On the HPLC systems used for screening, HbE elutes in the same window as HbA2, so a value of 25-30% in that window is far too high to be HbA2 and indicates HbE trait. HbE is common in north-east India and gives mild microcytosis with a normal or near-normal haemoglobin. Beta-thalassaemia trait raises true HbA2 only to about 3.5-7%. HbD Punjab and HbS each elute in their own windows, not in the A2 window.
- A: HbS elutes in its own S window, not the A2 window.
- C: HbD Punjab elutes in a separate D window on HPLC.
- D: Beta-thalassaemia trait gives HbA2 of about 3.5-7%, not 28%.