Question 1 · Hard
A 40-year-old man weighing 80 kg is having his creatinine clearance measured. His serum creatinine is 1.0 mg/dL [88 µmol/L]. He returns a 24-hour urine container holding 720 mL, and the urine creatinine is 100 mg/dL [8,840 µmol/L]. He mentions that he forgot to collect 'a couple of times' while at work. The laboratory's procedure states that adult men usually excrete about 20-25 mg of creatinine per kg of body weight per day [177-221 µmol/kg/day]. Which interpretation of these results is best?
- AValid result; low muscle mass lowers his creatinine
- BIncomplete collection; clearance is falsely low
- CTubular secretion falsely raising clearance
- DModerately reduced GFR, about 50 mL/min
Show answerHide answer
Answer: B · Incomplete collection; clearance is falsely low
Clearance = (U × V) / P = (100 mg/dL × 720 mL / 1,440 min) / 1.0 mg/dL = 50 mL/min. The container holds 100 mg/dL × 7.2 dL = 720 mg of creatinine, but an 80-kg man should excrete about 1,600 to 2,000 mg a day, so less than half the day's urine was collected. Because creatinine excretion is steady from day to day, total creatinine is the standard check of completeness for any 24-hour collection. With a normal serum creatinine and admitted missed voids, the low clearance is a collection error, not kidney disease. The test should be repeated with clear instructions to collect every void.
- A: An 80-kg man with a normal serum creatinine is not expected to have low muscle mass, and low creatinine output would not lower the clearance itself.
- C: Tubular secretion makes creatinine clearance overestimate GFR; it cannot explain a low clearance.
- D: A clearance of 50 mL/min would mean reduced GFR, but his creatinine excretion is far below expected, which points to missed urine.