Question 1 · Hard
A multiplex real-time RT-PCR for respiratory viruses is run on an extraction batch of 22 samples. Each batch includes a negative extraction control (viral transport medium taken through extraction) and a positive control, and each plate has a no-template control of water added at master-mix set-up. Results: sample 7, influenza A Ct 14.2; samples 6 and 8, from different wards, influenza A Ct 35.9 and 36.4; negative extraction control, in position 9, influenza A Ct 37.1; no-template control, no amplification; internal control normal in every well. The most likely explanation for the weak positives is:
- ALow viral loads in two true infections
- BPCR inhibition in samples 6, 8 and 9
- CCarry-over from sample 7 during extraction
- DAmplicon contamination of the PCR master mix
Show answerHide answer
Answer: C · Carry-over from sample 7 during extraction
The negative extraction control turned positive while the no-template control, added only at the PCR step, stayed negative, so the contamination entered before the master mix, during extraction. The weak positives sit right next to a very strong sample (Ct 14), the typical pattern of splash or aerosol carry-over between neighboring tubes or wells. Contaminated master mix or amplicon would also make the no-template control positive. Samples 6 and 8 are not reported as positive; they are re-extracted from the original specimens away from strong positives, and the extraction technique and plate layout are reviewed.
- A: The negative extraction control is positive too, so the signal is contamination.
- B: Internal controls are normal, and inhibition causes false negatives, not false positives.
- D: Contaminated master mix would also make the no-template control positive.