Question 1 · Hard
A 46-year-old man with type 2 diabetes cleans and sells freshwater fish at a market. He cuts his hand on a fin, and 2 days later the wound is swollen and draining pus. A Gram stain of the pus shows neutrophils and gram-negative rods, and culture grows a pure, lactose-non-fermenting, oxidase-negative gram-negative rod. Results: TSI K/A with gas and a heavy black butt; indole positive; citrate negative; urease negative; phenylalanine deaminase negative; lysine decarboxylase positive; ornithine decarboxylase positive; motile. Which organism fits best?
- AEdwardsiella tarda
- BNon-typhoidal Salmonella
- CCitrobacter freundii
- DProteus vulgaris
Show answerHide answer
Answer: A · Edwardsiella tarda
The isolate is an H2S-producing lactose non-fermenter that is also indole positive and lysine positive, a combination that fits Edwardsiella tarda. E. tarda lives in freshwater and marine fish and in reptiles, and causes wound infections and gastroenteritis in people who handle them. Salmonella is H2S and lysine positive too, but it is indole negative and usually citrate positive. Proteus vulgaris is indole and H2S positive but urease and phenylalanine deaminase positive and ornithine negative, and Citrobacter freundii is lysine negative and citrate positive. A Salmonella-like TSI with a positive indole is the clue to think of Edwardsiella.
- B: Salmonella is indole negative and usually citrate positive.
- C: C. freundii is lysine decarboxylase negative and citrate positive.
- D: P. vulgaris is urease and phenylalanine deaminase positive and ornithine negative.