Question 1 · Hard
Urine from a 66-year-old woman grows more than 10^8 CFU/L (10^5 CFU/mL) of small grey, non-hemolytic colonies on blood agar and small yellow colonies on CLED agar. A colony picked from the blood agar gives slow, weak bubbling in 3% hydrogen peroxide, so a staphylococcal identification card is set up; it returns 'unidentified organism'. Further results: Gram stain, gram-positive cocci in pairs and short chains; catalase on a colony from the CLED agar, negative; PYR positive; LAP positive; bile esculin positive; growth in 6.5% NaCl broth; vancomycin susceptible. The most likely organism is:
- AEnterococcus species
- BAerococcus viridans
- CStreptococcus agalactiae
- DStaphylococcus saprophyticus
Show answerHide answer
Answer: A · Enterococcus species
Weak, slow bubbling from a blood agar colony is a classic false-positive catalase: red cells picked up with the colony contain catalase, and some enterococci make a weak pseudocatalase on media that contain blood. The negative catalase on growth from CLED agar is the valid result, so the organism is a catalase-negative coccus in pairs and chains. PYR and LAP positivity, bile esculin hydrolysis and growth in 6.5% NaCl identify Enterococcus. Aerococcus viridans is LAP negative and grows in tetrads, and group B streptococci are PYR and bile esculin negative. Catalase should be tested on growth from a medium without blood.
- B: Aerococcus viridans is LAP negative and forms tetrads, not chains.
- C: Group B streptococci are PYR negative and bile esculin negative.
- D: Staphylococci are strongly catalase positive on any medium and grow in clusters.