Question 1 · Hard
Over 2 weeks, a TB laboratory reports scanty acid-fast bacilli (1 to 9 AFB per 100 oil-immersion fields) on Ziehl-Neelsen smears from seven new patients, but Xpert MTB/RIF on the same sputa is negative in all seven. This week the negative control slides, prepared from a known AFB-negative suspension, also show a few red rods, although the background and the other bacteria on every slide are evenly blue. The slides are new, they are stained flat on a rack and never dipped in shared jars, and the carbol fuchsin was freshly made and filtered. Since a plumbing repair, staff have rinsed the slides with tap water from a storage tank instead of distilled water. The most likely cause is:
- AAcid-fast saprophytes in the rinse water
- BCross-contamination of sputa during processing
- CBacilli carried between slides during staining
- DToo little decolorization of thick smears
Show answerHide answer
Answer: A · Acid-fast saprophytes in the rinse water
Scanty positive smears in several patients, all negative by Xpert, point to acid-fast rods that did not come from the patients. The negative control slides were prepared separately from patient material and are also positive, so the source lies in the staining process, not in the specimens. The evenly blue background rules out poor decolorization, and new slides stained flat on a rack make transfer between slides unlikely. Tap water and storage tanks often hold environmental mycobacteria, which is why AFB staining procedures call for distilled or filtered water for rinsing and for reagents. The water source should be changed and the affected reports reviewed and corrected.
- B: Processing errors cannot put acid-fast rods on negative control slides prepared separately.
- C: Slides stained flat on a rack are not exposed to bacilli from other smears, as they are in a shared jar.
- D: Under-decolorized smears have a red-tinged background; here the background is evenly blue.