Question 1 · Hard
On a Thursday evening, a clinic in Al Ain collects midstream urines for culture from two outpatients with dysuria. Urine 1 is put into a boric acid tube filled to the marked line and kept at room temperature (about 24 °C). Urine 2 is put into a plain sterile container and kept in the clinic refrigerator at 4 °C. Because of a public holiday, the courier delivers both specimens 30 hours after collection. Both are correctly labeled, neither has leaked, and the request forms are complete. The laboratory applies the standard holding limits for urine culture. What should the laboratory do?
- ACulture urine 2 and reject urine 1
- BCulture urine 1 and reject urine 2
- CReject both, as each is over 24 hours old
- DCulture both specimens with a delay comment
Show answerHide answer
Answer: B · Culture urine 1 and reject urine 2
Unpreserved urine must be plated within 2 hours or refrigerated, and refrigerated urine is acceptable for up to 24 hours. Boric acid holds the colony count steady for up to 48 hours at room temperature, provided the tube is filled to the line so that the preservative is at the right concentration. Urine 1 is within its 48-hour limit, but urine 2 has been held past its 24-hour limit, so its colony count may no longer reflect the bladder. Culturing it with a comment still risks a misleading result, and rejecting both would waste a valid specimen. The clinic should be asked for a fresh specimen from patient 2.
- A: This reverses the limits: the refrigerated urine is the one past its 24-hour limit.
- C: Boric acid keeps urine stable at room temperature for up to 48 hours, so urine 1 is acceptable.
- D: Culturing a specimen held past its limit, even with a comment, can give a misleading count.