Question 1 · Hard
A 58-year-old sheep farmer with a bioprosthetic aortic valve has had low-grade fevers, night sweats and weight loss for 4 months. Echocardiography shows a small vegetation on the valve. He took no antibiotics before three blood culture sets were drawn from separate sites, and all three are negative after 5 days in a continuous-monitoring system. Further results: Bartonella IgG negative; Brucella antibody negative; Coxiella burnetii IgG by immunofluorescence, phase I 1:4,096 and phase II 1:1,024. Which diagnosis best fits these results?
- AAcute Q fever without endocarditis
- BBartonella quintana endocarditis
- CChronic Q fever endocarditis
- DHACEK endocarditis missed by short incubation
Show answerHide answer
Answer: C · Chronic Q fever endocarditis
Blood cultures stay negative in Q fever because Coxiella burnetii is an obligate intracellular bacterium that does not grow in blood culture broth. The diagnosis is serologic: a very high phase I IgG titer, here also above the phase II titer, marks persistent (chronic) infection such as endocarditis, while acute Q fever shows phase II antibody higher than phase I. A phase I IgG titer above 1:800 is a major criterion for endocarditis. Contact with sheep and a prosthetic valve are classic risks. HACEK organisms are recovered within the standard 5 days in modern systems, and the Bartonella and Brucella tests are negative.
- A: Acute Q fever shows phase II antibody higher than phase I, not the reverse.
- B: Bartonella IgG is negative, and the Coxiella phase I titer explains the picture.
- D: HACEK organisms grow within the standard 5-day protocol in continuous-monitoring systems.