Question 1 · Hard
A 3-year-old girl lives with her grandfather, who has smear-positive cavitary tuberculosis. She has a chronic cough and weight loss but cannot produce sputum. Early-morning gastric aspirates are collected by nasogastric tube on three consecutive days, before she eats. The day 1 and day 3 aspirates are neutralized with sodium carbonate at the bedside and reach the laboratory within 1 hour. The day 2 aspirate is collected into a plain sterile tube, left at room temperature on the ward, and arrives 7 hours later without neutralization. All three are processed the same way. Mycobacterial cultures: day 1 and day 3 grow M. tuberculosis complex; day 2 shows no growth of any organism at 6 weeks. The most likely reason the day 2 culture is negative is:
- ADecontamination was too harsh for this specimen
- BToo few bacilli were swallowed that night
- CGastric acid killed the bacilli during the delay
- DContaminating flora overgrew the mycobacteria
Show answerHide answer
Answer: C · Gastric acid killed the bacilli during the delay
Young children swallow their respiratory secretions, so fasting early-morning gastric aspirates are used when sputum cannot be produced. Gastric acid kills mycobacteria, so the aspirate must be neutralized with sodium carbonate or processed promptly after collection. The day 2 specimen sat unneutralized for 7 hours, and a culture with no growth at all fits loss of viable bacilli; overgrowth would have given a contaminated culture instead. The other two aspirates grew with the same processing, so the decontamination step and the number of bacilli are unlikely causes. The day 2 result should be noted as compromised, and another neutralized aspirate collected if needed.
- A: All three aspirates had the same decontamination, and two grew M. tuberculosis.
- B: The other two aspirates grew readily, and the handling error is the better explanation.
- D: Overgrowth gives a contaminated culture, but this one grew nothing at all.