Question 1 · Hard
A newly trained technologist performs Ziehl-Neelsen stains on three sputum smears and the daily control slide, which carries an acid-fast Mycobacterium species and non-acid-fast Escherichia coli. The log shows: smears heat-fixed on a 70 °C slide warmer for 2 hours; carbol fuchsin flooded on for 5 minutes at room temperature, because the burner for the staining rack had been removed; 3% acid-alcohol applied until no more color ran off; methylene blue for 1 minute. On the control slide, both the mycobacteria and the E. coli are blue. No acid-fast bacilli are seen on the patient smears. The most likely cause of the control failure is:
- AThe smears were heat-fixed for too long
- BThe acid-alcohol decolorizer was too weak
- CCarbol fuchsin was applied without heat
- DMethylene blue was left on too long
Show answerHide answer
Answer: C · Carbol fuchsin was applied without heat
Ziehl-Neelsen is the hot acid-fast method: the slide is heated until it steams so that carbol fuchsin can penetrate the waxy mycolic acid layer of the cell wall. Applied cold for 5 minutes, the primary stain never entered the mycobacteria, so the decolorizer removed what little they held and they took up the blue counterstain like E. coli. A weak decolorizer causes the opposite error, leaving non-acid-fast cells red. Heat fixing at 65 to 75 °C for 2 hours is standard for AFB smears. The patient smears must be restained correctly, or by the Kinyoun cold method with its stronger reagent, and reported only after the control passes.
- A: Heat fixing at 65-75 °C for 2 hours is the standard for AFB smears.
- B: A weak decolorizer leaves non-acid-fast cells red; it does not turn acid-fast bacilli blue.
- D: A long counterstain does not remove carbol fuchsin from properly stained acid-fast bacilli.