Question 1 · Hard
A 54-year-old man who cleans his freshwater aquarium by hand has had watery diarrhea and cramps for 4 days; he has not traveled. His stool grows blue-green colonies with black centers on Hektoen enteric agar. The isolate is an oxidase-negative, lactose-nonfermenting gram-negative rod with these reactions: TSI K/A with H2S and gas; indole positive; urease negative; lysine decarboxylase positive; citrate negative; motile. It does not agglutinate in Salmonella polyvalent O antiserum. Which organism is most likely?
- AProteus vulgaris
- BEdwardsiella tarda
- CSalmonella enterica
- DCitrobacter freundii
Show answerHide answer
Answer: B · Edwardsiella tarda
Black-centered colonies on Hektoen agar and an H2S-positive K/A TSI suggest Salmonella, but the indole reaction separates the look-alikes. Edwardsiella tarda is H2S positive, indole positive, lysine decarboxylase positive and citrate negative, and it is linked to fish, fresh water and reptiles. Salmonella is indole negative and usually citrate positive, and it would normally agglutinate in polyvalent O antiserum. Citrobacter freundii is indole negative, citrate positive and lysine negative, and Proteus vulgaris is urease positive. Checking the full biochemical profile before reporting stops a Salmonella mimic from being reported as Salmonella.
- A: P. vulgaris is urease positive and lysine decarboxylase negative.
- C: Salmonella is indole negative, usually citrate positive, and agglutinates in polyvalent O antiserum.
- D: C. freundii is indole negative, lysine decarboxylase negative and citrate positive.